PCB Surface Finishes: HASL, OSP and ENIG

Understanding PCB Surface Finishes: HASL, OSP, and ENIG

For additional details on lead-free hasl, please reach out to us, and we will provide expert guidance.

When it comes to selecting surface finishes for printed circuit boards (PCBs), a choice exists between organic and metallic materials. While identifying the various types of surface finishes is straightforward, determining the optimal choice for your PCB can be more complex. Although these finishes share common features, each one brings its unique advantages, drawbacks, and technical considerations.

This article aims to provide insights into three prevalent types of surface finishes: Hot Air Solder Leveling (HASL), Organic Solderability Preservative (OSP), and Electroless Nickel Immersion Gold (ENIG), helping you to make an informed decision.

Significance of PCB Surface Finish

The choice of surface finish plays a crucial role in determining the quality and functionality of the PCB within its corresponding application. The surface finish acts as a barrier to prevent oxidation of the copper layer on the PCB, which could otherwise diminish solderability. By implementing a finishing process, the PCB is protected from oxidation prior to the installation of components, enabling successful soldering of additional elements. Given that the connectivity of the PCB underpins its electrical performance, preventing oxidation is essential for ensuring proper solder attachment of components.

Choosing the correct finish involves various factors, including the finishing method, PCB design, and desired quality of the end product. It’s important to note that not every finish type is suitable for every PCB, and several characteristics should be considered when assessing the options:

1. Solderability

Ensuring effective soldering is vital for producing a well-functioning PCB. A smooth surface facilitates an effective connection in its operational environment. Evaluate whether the chosen surface finish allows for direct soldering to copper, as is the case with immersion tin, versus a layered approach like ENIG.

Additionally, wire bonding is an important aspect to consider, as different metals necessitate distinct manufacturing practices and exhibit varying behaviors in similar conditions. The wires may be made from materials like aluminum, gold, or copper, and the compatibility of each surface finish type with these metals varies.

2. Processing Time

The duration of the finishing process can vary significantly; for example, HASL tends to have a larger processing window.

The amount of time required for the process will be influenced by the complexity of the assembly. For instance, surface finishes like OSP tend to have limited thermal cycles and are not suited for enduring multiple soldering processes. After some cycles, the finish will degrade, compromising the protection against oxidation. That said, OSP surface finishes can often be reworked during fabrication, similar to immersion silver.

ENIG involves a more intricate finishing method, implying a longer processing time, which could make it a more suitable option for production lines where high throughput is not a necessity.

3. Reliability

How well the chosen surface finish withstands environmental factors must be taken into account. If specific reliability standards are a requirement for your PCB, selecting a finish that can meet these expectations is critical. Cost is only one aspect among many to consider, especially regarding the implications of a failure in the PCB’s finish and its subsequent inability to protect the board surface.

The IPC outlines a series of standards within its TM-650 Test Methods Manual that delve into various testing methods for PCB reliability and quality. Techniques include dimensional verification, chemical resistance assessments, copper ductility tests, and evaluations of signal loss. One such test utilizes materials like sulfuric acid and isopropanol to examine their effects on the dielectric materials of the PCB.

4. Corrosion

Some surface finishes, such as silver, are more prone to creep corrosion than others. This form of corrosion can manifest with nearly all finish types, yet it is particularly prevalent with immersion silver. As metal corrosion propagates across the PCB’s surface, it can lead to short circuits due to interference with adjacent features on the board. This issue has become increasingly apparent with the rise of lead-free finishes, as lead was historically effective in combating corrosion.

Creep corrosion is also more frequently observed in humid and sulfur-rich settings. It's important to consider the environment your PCBs will be exposed to before selecting a specific surface finish, as environmental factors significantly influence product lifespan.

Other finishes like immersion tin may develop whiskers, although the use of anti-migration agents can mitigate this concern.

Influential Factors in PCB Surface Finishing Selection

A range of factors will affect the type of PCB finish you decide to utilize. It is crucial to evaluate these factors collectively, as favoring one characteristic too heavily may hinder the outcome of the final PCB. For instance, opting for cost-effective lead-free HASL might reveal concerns regarding co-planarity in comparison to alternative finishing methods.

1. Cost

The expenses associated with surface finishing are contingent upon the selected type. The quality of the finish also contributes to the total cost. Generally, HASL finishes are more budget-friendly than ENIG, yet they may not always meet the specific quality standards required for your application.

The expenditure for fabricating the board itself is another consideration. Following the initial fabrication, assess whether there is flexibility within your budget to explore more advanced finishing techniques like ENIG. PCBs utilized in consumer electronics tend to be less expensive to manufacture, allowing for the possibility of utilizing costlier finishes that yield superior results.

If you need further insights, feel free to check out multilayer pcb design tips.

2. Volume

The scale of production can profoundly influence your choice of surface finishing. For instance, immersion tin finishes may begin to tarnish shortly after application on copper PCBs. However, deploying a large quantity of PCBs can help mitigate the tarnishing issue. For smaller batches, a finish like immersion silver might prove more effective.

3. Aesthetics

Methods such as HASL and OSP often possess better visual appeal compared with ENIG, which is another factor that could sway your decision. Do you require a gleaming surface that withstands creep corrosion, whiskers, and related problems? In such cases, you might prefer alternatives that are less likely to induce significant corrosion.

Overview of PCB Surface Finishing Methods

Several types of PCB surface finishes are available, but the focus here will be on three prominent options: HASL, OSP, and ENIG.

1. HASL and Lead-Free HASL

A HASL surface finish offers excellent solderability and accommodates multiple thermal cycles. Historically, it was the industry standard; however, shifts due to the Restriction of Hazardous Substances (RoHS) have necessitated the adoption of lead-free HASL as a more acceptable solution concerning health and environmental impacts. While traditional HASL is recognized in the industry, lead-free HASL stands as a safer alternative compliant with RoHS directives.

To create a HASL finish, the PCB is immersed in a tin-lead or tin-nickel solder bath for a specified duration. After removal, excess solder is eliminated using air knives. Despite its large processing window, various elements can influence the uniformity of the finish and hence the solderability. Factors such as the air knife angle, air pressure, and the rate of PCB entry and exit from the solder bath all play a role in the final finish quality.

Applications for HASL and lead-free HASL include:

• Electrical Testing: HASL finishes offer inherent protection for vias and test pads during PCB electrical testing.
• Hand Soldering: They are suitable for hand soldering techniques, allowing for easy formation of solder joints.
• High-Performance Electronics: Given its ability to create robust joints, HASL is often favored for high-reliability applications in industries such as aerospace and military.

2. OSP

OSP represents an organic finishing option for PCBs. This environmentally friendly process avoids harmful chemicals and retains protective and anti-corrosive properties. Consequently, OSP boards are compliant with RoHS standards. The water-based finish provides a flat surface ideal for attaching additional components, making it a cost-effective alternative to lead-free HASL.

As a replacement for lead-free HASL, OSP offers superior co-planarity. When seeking a PCB surface finish that guarantees sufficient flatness and straightforward manufacturing processes, OSP is often the optimal choice.

The OSP application involves a combination of conveyorized chemical processes or vertical dip tanks, typically following these steps:

1. Cleaning: The PCB’s copper surface is thoroughly cleaned to remove contaminants that may affect finish flatness.
2. Topography Enhancement: Micro-etching enhances the exposed copper surface, increasing adhesion for the OSP while minimizing oxidation.
3. Acid Rinse: The PCB is treated with a sulfuric acid solution rinse.
4. OSP Application: The OSP solution is subsequently applied to the PCB.
5. Deionization Rinse: This step introduces ions to facilitate easy elimination during soldering and should occur prior to any build-up of preservatives to prevent tarnishing.
6. Drying: Post-application of the OSP, the PCB must be thoroughly dried.

While OSP offers an easy and economical process, keep in mind it is sensitive to handling, as scratches can impair solderability. Moreover, its shelf life is not as extensive as that of ENIG or HASL.

Common applications for OSP include:

• Fine Pitch Devices: Preferred for fine pitch components due to the absence of co-planar pads or uneven surfaces.
• Server Boards: Suitable for varied applications, from basic to high-frequency server boards, and often utilized for selective finish applications.
• Surface Mount Technology (SMT): OSP works effectively for direct component attachment onto PCB surfaces.

3. ENIG

With a higher price tag, ENIG surface finishing consistently delivers premium quality products. This method is resilient under multiple thermal cycles, exhibits excellent solderability, and suits wire bonding applications. ENIG comprises two layers: nickel for copper protection and gold as an anti-corrosion barrier for the nickel layer.

ENIG is particularly beneficial where tight tolerances for PCB features like plated holes are crucial, an area where HASL may fall short. Alongside OSP, it provides excellent flatness, making it ideal for fine pitch components.

The ENIG application process entails depositing nickel onto a palladium-catalyzed copper surface, followed by immersion gold application through molecular exchange. The process includes micro-etching and rinsing between stages, involving the following steps:

1. Cleaning.
2. Micro-etching.
3. Pre-dipping.
4. Applying the activator.
5. Post-dipping.
6. Application of electroless nickel.
7. Application of immersion gold.

Standard applications for ENIG surface finishes include:

• Complex Surface Components: Due to its flat profile, ENIG is favored for intricate PCB components needing smooth surfaces, such as ball grid arrays (BGAs) and quad flat packages (QFPs).
• Wire Bonding: ENIG facilitates improved wire bonding for aluminum wires while presenting compatibility challenges with gold.
• High Reliability Applications: ENIG surface finishes are prevalent in sectors such as aerospace, military, medical, and high-end consumer products, where precision and durability are paramount.

Contact Millennium Circuits Limited for Further Guidance on PCB Surface Finishes

With an array of surface finishes available, navigating your options can be daunting. Fortunately, Millennium Circuits Unlimited is here to help you through the decision-making process.

MCL specializes in printed circuit board supply, providing both small batch and large volume PCBs to clients globally. As an ISO-certified PCB company, we possess extensive knowledge earned through years of experience in PCBs and their intricacies. Since our focus is solely on PCBs and related components, we're well-equipped to address any inquiries or concerns you may have about this technology.

To gather more information about PCB surface finishes and explore your options, please contact us today by either completing our online form or calling us at 717-558-.

For additional insights, please visit pcb surface finish comparison.